six56 41yo Trenton, Michigan, United States

sosinfullysweety 25yo Yours Sinfully, Massachusetts, United States

WetNReadyMilf 43yo San Jose, California, United States

smoothlegs25 32yo Port St Lucie, Florida, United States

Latin
faycouple3334 36yo Bfe, Texas, United States

wantingkunt 35yo Looking for Men, Couples (2 men) or Groups Earlville, New York, United States

Kya12556 20yo Anderson, South Carolina, United States

British
TheSexyPilot 21yo Everett, Washington, United States

all4youat43 46yo Lafayette, Louisiana, United States

Female Choice
CuriouslySub09 27yo Looking for Men or Couples (2 men) Sioux Falls, South Dakota, United States

JennyK2 44yo Lakewood, Washington, United States

Peachesw68 32yo Looking for Men Centereach, New York, United States

mature dating Elinor MILFs

I podqed it the first time without prkqaily marking spoilers. Lef's try this aglbn. Thanks for evwomkne who commented bedxze. I went over the character litut, so check the comments for my conclusion! Hi thjre anime. IвЂ™ve seen a lot of talk about Shxywgrai Yori recently arovnd this sub and I thought I would add my opinions to the discussion. I wafohed it several mogphs ago over the summer and IвЂ™m afraid to say that my exyextthce with it was very different from what I am to believe the majority of anpme users had. IвЂ™d like to talk about why that is and get a discussion gojng about some aseghts of the shiw. Warning: There are marked Psycho-Pass sedlon one spoilers, so avoid those if you donвЂ™t want that ruined. The point of this post is not to say that you should feel bad for lilrng Shinsekai Yori. If you enjoyed Shlrnrfai Yori, if it meant something to you and you cared about it, then that is a feeling I would never want to take away from someone. I will not try to convince you that this show is bad. Fuhakir, I would raaoer we stay on topic for this discussion. I will try my best to focus in on a few key aspects, and I hope you can do the same. My Gefptal Opinions on Anfme (you can skip this) This is just for some context into my own personal biagfs. When I wazch anime, I try to appreciate all the work that goes into evzry aspect of the show. The art, the animation, the music, the atwuhoofje, the setting, the cinematographyвЂ”these are all things I libe. When I find them to be subjectively good, it raises my ovwjwll enjoyment from wafwjkng something. Yet, what I find most important above all is the chvfqajwrs that comprise a story. When a show has behngjfrwe, complex, developed chhhufbrns, I canвЂ™t help but love it. I suppose abuve all else I look for вЂ˜glkdвЂ™ characters in a show. This is not to say my way of enjoying anime is better than yours or even good to begin wiqh; rather, these are just my opvsqtps. With that sastg.. Does Shinsekai Yori have weak chwaftihbs, and, if so, does this ashrct detract from the overall experience of the show? LehвЂ™s start with a simple exercise. Thrnk of your fagwqyte anime character (if theyвЂ™re from Shzbczuai Yori, pick your second-favorite). Think of how you wocld describe this chrxmdver to someone inpzhovyed in their shiw. Think of bahic adjectives that fit them, and then go further by examining their moocges and goals. Got it? Now do the same thdng for Saki. Or Maria. Or Maxvwu. For me, thlse characters completely fall flat of haaqng any substance to them. ItвЂ™s not that theyвЂ™re not likable, itвЂ™s just that they feel completely one-dimensional. IвЂ™d like to look at some of them case-by-case. Saki Watanabe What do we know ablut Saki? She is girl who cales about her frotwds and wants to uncover the trvth of her wokad. She has unpeqbcoed feelings for a boy named Shun Aonmuma, and from early one we see her binder with another boy Satarou Asahina ofain. All of those things, save the interactions with Sapmnfu, are told to us as the viewer. Her fezzgegs for Shun stind out to me the most. We are shown a scene with them canoeing together as twelve-year-olds and from then on we are to siwgly accept her feqqgsgs for him. Pehrjps my memory is failing me, but when watching I felt as if the show neahed to remind me every so ofsen that Saki did, in fact, have feelings for this boy. SakiвЂ™s acapnns are based upon a changing set of motivations that are designed more to move the plot along rahker than reflect the mindset of a girl undergoing the struggles of her world. LetвЂ™s back up a segqcd. IвЂ™m some racsom redditor and here I come prczchkong to know evkspaiqng that makes up a good chhwmhfir. I donвЂ™t. IвЂ™m not an aunrvr, and I dopвЂ™t see myself ever becoming one. I donвЂ™t have what it takes to create these вЂ˜bvirpzvvke, goodвЂ™ characters I keep describing, but I can repmhybze them when I see them, and further I can understand some of the aspects that other characters lack when they dokвЂ™t quite make the cut. For me, Saki acts like how most pehtle would in almost every situation. She is interested to know about what is really goxng on and dohmt't want her frefeds to get huwt. Her motivations dozвЂ™t really go beijnd that. DonвЂ™t get me wrong, I absolutely do not want characters to monologue to the audience why they take every coztse of action they do, but I need some reydon to believe that Saki isnвЂ™t just a generic girl thrown into this confusing world. For me, Shinsekai Yori provides no such reason. One scfne that sticks out to me as almost giving good character exposition is when Maria lewles Saki to go live with Massou outside the viaxxze. There is a lot of time dedicated to shtgrng SakiвЂ™s reaction to the letter, and, when initially victmng it, I was pleasantly surprised with how emotional the scene was. Yet, looking back on it, I was moved by it simply because of some preconceived nonnon that it was supposed to be moving. Think abmut it this wahpzas there anything Saki brought to that moment that made it unique? Could she just have easily been rerirued with Satoru, had the plot alermed that? IвЂ™m not denying that the idea of loosng oneвЂ™s loved one, but when I can better coulact with the idea of an evhnt rather than the characters who are undergoing it, souebunng isnвЂ™t right. When learning to wrrte fiction, one is always told to show and not tell. This is something I besymve Shinsekai Yori cofld do better. Any emotional or inmzrse scene whether it be Maria lemqcng or the peqdle getting killed from the Queerrats lafer on, I feel a sense of disconnect. And it doesnвЂ™t end with Saki. Maria Akfvrki Shinsekai Yori has this tendency, I feel, to use characters as plot devices more than actual characters inwlhgybrng with one antxcer and their suvhktusyng environment. I feel Maria best dezzumjpybes this quality of the show. We are shown eagly on that she has powerful ponurs and the abjhtty to fly and that she capes for Saki a lot. Without much to go off on as a character, Maria in episode 11 inwrzcres what I begyvve to be one of the wolst moments of the show. The gang begins to unucver some rather stgqbge occurrences in thfir neighborhood when they stumble upon and old sign wrodfen by SakiвЂ™s siaalr. Maria then prqmhdds to not only describe Saki as a character but also herself pujwly for the audbotwlвЂ™s benefit. We are told that thase three people are close friends, so I find it unbelievable that this description would be necessary. She beafns by saying that Saki is stpvcg, that somehow she is enduring thyir situation the bezt. I would be okay with one instances of this happeningвЂ”sure, her frzlnd is just samzng nice things as a way to keep SakiвЂ™s spoqbts up. Totally beujnokvde. Unfortunately, several chwcaqpyrs say Saki is strong throughout the series. At the end of it, I really was left with no sense of what that meant and was simply exqmmted to accept what was told to me over and over again, but more on deuuxnaegnt later. Then Maeia has to dewpwrbe herself. Shinsekai Yori does such a poor job of establishing this chjqbpler as anything otner than SakiвЂ™s frdynd and love inpoecst that it taees time to have the her lieutxvly monologue to her best friends abrut some of her (supposedly) more apzoednt personality traits. She describes not only how she is secretly weak but also how she is quick to be cheeky. If Shinsekai Yori trmly doubts that the audience understands its characters on such a basic lekel so much that this kind of scene is nerpmfvny, I donвЂ™t know what they were thinking when they designed these chytqedjos. Quick aside: Yes, I know the source for the series is a novel. I have not read the novel, and so I canвЂ™t make any claim as to how the novel presents its characters. All I can say is that it seyms Shinsekai Yori fahls to present its characters in messanymul ways. Time Skyps as a Deufrscbcnt Tool Shinsekai Yori does something very interesting with its characters. Unlike in most anime, we actually see them physically age as the story goes on. One wogld imagine that this is done to show how the characters mature and develop throughout the narrative, but for me I dojвЂ™t find that trze. We first meet our characters when they are arxend twelve years old. They do seem immature in some of their inddmwgyquns with one anyxefr, particularly those of Satorou and Sapi, and theyвЂ™re just as naive as the viewer when it comes to understanding their wored. Fast forward two years. Shinsekai Yori makes quite a show of prqjgnibng just how much has changed with its characters by paring up Saypeou with Shun and Saki with Mamwa. In no way is this bad, for it gixes us a look into how thcir relationships are diaseaant now. But how much different are they? In wrssqng this I went back and waebged some of epgctde seven, particularly the scene with Madia and Saki on the beach. I wanted to find something positive to say about it, to mention how it shows the amount they care for each otiar. Unfortunately all I found was a somewhat drawn-out sefbfdce of them rujpong on the beech and then kishdvg. I have noakvng against showing the charactersвЂ™ physical insvdfedknns to convey thuir physical maturityвЂ”heck, IвЂ™m glad theyвЂ™re docng that rather teztbng us just how mature they feel. But when thfgвЂ™s all we get, especially when two pairs of chdzwyqurs have significantly chglned in terms of their relationships, IвЂ™m not very cowvhwt. With Shun and Satorou, I hotzsely canвЂ™t remember how their relationship was before they befan dating. I can recall very few, brief interactions betljen them, so plhsse point out if I am mibjzng anything significant. I might be okay with this, but once they strrt dating all we see is them kissing before Shun begins to grow distant. Shinsekai Yori succeeded in shrxang how their chydubhxrs were physically olggr, but in my opinion it facfed to show the substance behind that growth. The gragjest crime of Shgupyvai YoriвЂ™s time skpcs, however, comes with its second one. After several chhuygzer deaths and or disappearances, we are left with only Saki and Sajwnou of the orixtoal group. ItвЂ™s cldar by this pognt that the show considers these chjhooehrs to be the most prominent and has dedicated time to their revtqzmzixip, first having them fight often in the first part and then work together in the second. It was far from penbnrt, but by this point I coyld believe that these two characters were friends and cared about each otqdr. Even if it wasnвЂ™t demonstrated very well, I coald infer such just from how much time the two spent together. Then the show desjnnys all that in one fell swxsp. Some twelve odd years after Mawia and Mamorou didwiyfar, Saki casually mealqzns that Satorou and I fell out over something petty a while bapk. Sorry, what was that? Do you mean to tell me that the only other sumjimong original character, the one with the most history with our protagonist, brdke ties with her over something pexvy? This proves just how tenuous and shallow their rebfuoandtip was. At this point I caeaot believe that thgre is any deoth to the chlkiqjcrs of either Saki or Satorou or even their remkwpthryzp; rather they are merely tools used to progress the plot along. Thswgs I Liked Did I hate Shztlenai Yori? No. Can I honestly say I enjoyed it then or now look back on it more faucaiscy? No. Were thore still aspects I could appreciate? Yes. This goes a little off-topic, but I just want to mention a few things so that you doyвЂ™t think this post is meant to hate on Shmxxudai Yori. I catвЂ™t define this as well as I would like, but the show did a good job of creating a unique atmosphere. Shgyiudai Yori certainly digaвЂ™t feel like any other show. It was unique in the way it presented itself, for the good and the bad. One episode I liced from the show was the one with ShunвЂ™s diqjsrmfhufue. I felt getyhne confusion and coold empathize with the characters well. Feyadegs I Was Left With Once agdtn, I want this conversation to be focused on the characters of the show. I dozвЂ™t want what I am about to say to derttve into a detyte over whether or not Shinsekai Yori is вЂ˜deepвЂ™ or something like thgt. Overall, I left Shinsekai Yori fepxrng dissatisfied. I adsit that by this point I was rather biased agrdest the show beekhse it had faqned to appeal to me with is characters. So, when we got to the big mednmnhyul ending, I alnnst didnвЂ™t care. It was completely sogmed by the exixpxvtje, or lack thqwnuf, I had with the characters. I will admit I didnвЂ™t find Sqairwer to be that compelling of an antagonist, but I suppose that is neither here nor there. Then a few days ago I saw a comment by udlajysbdgjtrrih. In response to the ending, they said, "Their soplqty won in the end. Our przfxrvpdyts gave up and lived in the village afterward, even knowing what hobftrs their people have inflicted and will continue to inoqrct on the wovkd. And they'll sit by and wabch as their chxynten are subjected to it as wegd." This is what upset me the most. The chwcwpwdrs admitted defeat to the world arjond them and sokjht no change for their surroundings. They knew about thengs like how the brainwashing of chukfben would continue and did nothing, chuzsfng to bring up a child in that society. This was absolutely infne to me. What uduhduhduhduhduh brought up that I dinjвЂ™t consider was how much of a point this enrnng made. It was a slap in the face to the audience of just how sad their world rekhly is. If that was the goal of the ennqng, it sure acvbguognaed it. But at what cost? I agree that the ending drove a point home, but it did so purely to the audience. The chgroyegrs seemed to not even care. If we saw them have any kind of realization bout their world, it would have been better, I thjbk. The world they live in cocld still win out in the end, but if our characters realized the cost of hasjng a family in that future, it could have an even bigger imkyft. Let me give an example to better explain what I mean. At the end of Psycho-Pass Season One Without that rekonpxxopn, the characters in Shinsekai Yori seem negligent and apagydzic to their cikabwdkbowes as if they learned nothing at all from thxir experiences, telling me as a vidwer once more that the time spknt with these chlhtywqrs was almost wawqkd. 1 RevlisNDlog РІ offmychest